Affiliate Disclosure: Links on this page may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate policy
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Books in Order
Below you'll find the complete list of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries books in publication order. This is generally the recommended reading order for the series.
Reading order verified: March 2026
Quick Answer
What order should I read the Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries series? Start with "Peace Like a River (By: Olivia Newport)" (2015) and follow publication order through all 27 books.
The complete Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries reading order is listed below in publication sequence.
Publication Order
Peace Like a River (By: Olivia Newport)
2015
Blessing in Disguise (By: Nancy Mehl)
2015
Where Hope Dwells (By: Elizabeth Ludwig)
2015
The Buggy Before the Horse
2015
A Season of Secrets (By: Elizabeth Adams)
2015
O Little Town of Sugarcreek (By: Amy Lee Lillard)
2015
Off the Beaten Path (By: Annalisa Daughety)
2015
Simply Vanished (By: Nancy Mehl)
2016
Stranger Things Have Happened (By: Amy Lillard)
2016
No Time for Trouble (By: Olivia Newport)
2016
A Stitch in Time (By: Elizabeth Ludwig)
2016
Shoo, FLY, Shoo (By: Amy Lillard)
2016
Home Sweet Sugarcreek (By: Elizabeth Ludwig)
2016
When There's a Will (By: Elizabeth Adams)
2016
In a Jam (By: Elizabeth Adams)
2016
All Abuzz at the Honey Bee (By: Nancy Mehl)
2016
Mason Jar Mayhem (By: Cara C. Putman)
2016
Earthly Treasures (By: Annalisa Daughety)
2016
A Tempting Taste Of Mystery (By: Elizabeth Ludwig)
2017
Digging Up Doubts (By: Olivia Newport)
2017
A Play On Words (By: Emily Thomas)
2017
In the Fullness of Time (By: Elizabeth Adams)
2017
Horse Sense and Sensibility (By: Nancy Mehl)
2017
Secrets Plain and Simple (By: Elizabeth Ludwig)
2018
When Angels Whisper (By: Nancy Mehl)
2022
Hark! The Herald Angel Falls
2024
O Little Town of Sugarcreek (By: Amy Lillard)
2025
Affiliate Disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, Reading Order Books earns from qualifying purchases. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. This helps us maintain the site and continue providing reading order guides. Read our full disclosure