Return to Starlight Bay Books in Order
Below you'll find the complete list of Return to Starlight Bay books in publication order. This is generally the recommended reading order for the series.
Reading order verified: January 2026
Publication Order
My One & Goalie (By: Kara Kendrick)
Buy on Amazon2025
Heavy Petting (By: Rose Bak)
Buy on Amazon2025
Brewed Awakening (By: Havana Wilder)
Buy on Amazon2025
Cupid's Beau
Buy on Amazon2025
Purrfect Planning (By: Tamrin Banks)
Buy on Amazon2025
Boss Me Not (By: A.J. Ranney)
Buy on Amazon2025
Played by the Fool (By: Natalie Arthur)
Buy on Amazon2025
A Good Egg (By: Annee Jones)
Buy on Amazon2025
The Umpire Strikes Back (By: Logan Chance)
Buy on Amazon2025
Pour Timing (By: Carolina Jax)
Buy on Amazon2025
Dare to Love (By: C.N. Marie)
Buy on Amazon2025
Strings Attached (By: StellaBella)
Buy on Amazon2025
Boss's Red Glare (By: Lizzie Sparks)
Buy on Amazon2025
Sinfully Sweet (By: Matilda Martel)
Buy on Amazon2025
Fore Better or Worse (By: Ellen Brooks)
Buy on Amazon2025
Beehive Yourself (By: Alexandra Hale)
Buy on Amazon2025
The Parent Pick-Up (By: Jill Brashear)
Buy on Amazon2025
Forever the Bully (By: Layne Daniels)
Buy on Amazon2025
Single Dad Hottie (By: Annie Charme)
Buy on Amazon2025
Holidate Scramble (By: Annee Jones)
Buy on Amazon2025
Tee the Season (By: Ellen Brooks)
Buy on Amazon2025
Miss Merry and Mr. Bright (By: Tamrin Banks)
Buy on Amazon2025
Mr. Mistletoe (By: Jill Brashear)
Buy on Amazon2025
Mr. Merry Ex-Mas (By: Carolina Jax)
Buy on Amazon2025
Say Yule Stay (By: Alexandra Hale)
Buy on Amazon2025
Fake Christmas Vows (By: Stella Bella)
Buy on Amazon2025
Mistletoe Mis-Chief (By: Annie Charme)
Buy on Amazon2025
Perfect Chemis-Tree (By: Gail Haris)
Buy on Amazon2025
Christmas in Starlight (By: Robecca Austin)
Buy on Amazon2025
Frequently Asked Questions
The recommended reading order for the Return to Starlight Bay series is publication order: 1. My One & Goalie (By: Kara Kendrick) (2025), 2. Heavy Petting (By: Rose Bak) (2025), 3. Brewed Awakening (By: Havana Wilder) (2025), 4. Cupid's Beau (2025), 5. Purrfect Planning (By: Tamrin Banks) (2025), and 24 more. This is generally the best way to experience the story as the author intended.
The Return to Starlight Bay series by Imani Jay contains 29 books. The series began in 2025 and continues to be a popular choice for readers.
The Return to Starlight Bay series is written by Imani Jay. You can find more books and series by this author on our website.
Reader Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!
Be the first to leave a review!